|
|
Neurobiology of preferences
Neurobiology of preferences
The
Neurobiology of Preferences
Mkael Symmonds & Raymond Dolan, University
College London
In:- Neuroscience of Preference and Choice – Eds. – Raymond
Dolan & Tali Sharot
Keywords: neuroscience
of preference/choice, consciousness, orbitofrontal, dopamine P. As far back as
the 1960s neuroscience had demonstrated a clear correlation between laboratory
rats pressing a lever apparently for pleasure and the electrical stimulation of
subcortical dopamine structures. The dopamine system is ancient from an
evolutionary point of view. It is shown that fruit flies can make choices that
are supported by their dopamine system, without the need for a highly developed
prefrontal cortex. Although preferences are seen to be rooted in biology, they
also appear flexible and sometimes even inconsistent. However, there is also
thought to be a sometimes unconscious default in favour of the status quo. This
default requires enhanced neural activity to overcome it, and this is related
to activity in the subthalamic nucleus.
The orbitofrontal cortex appears to
play an important role in representing the value of sensory inputs, but it does
not act in isolation, having reciprocal connections with the parietal,
cingulate and insula cortices and with subcortical areas such as the basal
ganglia, all of which are involved in evaluation of sensory inputs. A
distinction is made between 'wanting' and 'liking'. The latter is taken to
refer to immediate sensory pleasure, while 'wanting' is related to longer-term
anticipated rewards. The authors here suggest that 'liking' depends on an
endogenous opiod system, while 'wanting' is related to the dopamine system. The
authors also touch on the existence of 'exploratory behaviour' that goes beyond
established preferences. This behaviour appears to derive from parts of the
prefrontal. The authors think in terms of preferences being based on
communication between a network of brain regions rather than any individual
region.
A study by Gottfried, O'Doherty & Dolan (2003) showed responses
that were not directly related to the stimulus, but where activation decreased,
when satiety with a particular sensory input occurred. This study involved
activity in the orbitofrontal, the amygdala, the piriform cortex and the
midbrain, but only particular sub-regions of the orbitofrontal and the amygdala
decreased in response to satiety. Reductions in activity in line with satiety
were also observed in the insula cortex and the striatum in the basal ganglia. Recordings
in the orbitofrontal have shown a correlation between preferences and the activity
of single neurons.
Dopaminergic neurons located in the ventral tegmental and
substantia nigra (SN) regions of the mid brain vary their firing in response to
reward stimuli, but dopamine release does not always correlate to preference. One
suggestion is that these areas monitor the relationship between predicted
reward and reward obtained. There are specific dopaminergic projections to
brain regions, particularly the striatum and areas of the prefrontal. Modulation
of dopamine in the orbitofrontal and the striatum is related to decision
taking. The orbitofrontal is particularly involved with the evaluation of
stimuli where there has been a learning process, but the anterior cingulate
also appears to be involved in the evaluation of actions.
Dopamine depletion
in both the ventral striatum area of the basal ganglia and the interior
cingulate leads to reduced disposition to making physical efforts. Other
neurotransmitters such as noradrenaline and serotonin are thought to be
involved in risky decision taking.
|
|