|
|
Whole Brain
Whole Brain
New Scientist: 28 March 2009: Anil Ananthaswamy: based on Raphael Gaillard of INSERM
Raphael
Gaillard of INSERM took the opportunity provided by the need to insert
intercranial electrodes during medical treatments to test aspects of
consciousness. The sample of electrodes across 10 volunteers covered
most parts of the brain. Words were flashed in front of the volunteers,
some of which they were conscious of, and some of which were masked so
that there would only be unconscious processing. During the first 30
milliseconds there was not much difference between conscious and
unconscious processing. After that time, there were several types of
brain processing that only occurred where the subjects were conscious of
the words concerned. The frequency and phase of neurons in different
parts of the brain synchronised, and then in turn set of synchronised
signals in other parts of the brain. For instance activity in the
occipital lobes seemed to set off activity in the frontal lobes. The
fact that this only occurred when subjects were aware of the words being
shown, meant that this synchronisation was viewed by the researchers as
a correlate of consciousness. The synchronisation of activity was
spread over large parts of the brain leading the researchers to
hypothesise that consciousness is spread over a large part of the brain
rather than being concentrated in any one ‘seat of consciousness’.
The
clear distinction here between conscious and non-conscious processing
appears to contradict a core theme of Dennett to the effect that there
is no such distinction between conscious and non-conscious activity. It
also seems to argue against the once popular ‘electric plug’ theory of
consciousness. This argued that consciousness was concentrated in and
around the brain stem, because if anything seriously damaged the brain
stem consciousness ceased. This research would rather seem to suggest
that the brain stem is necessary but not sufficient for human
consciousness.
The findings appear compatible with the idea that
the widespread gamma synchrony is a correlate of consciousness. This
view was made popular by, although not discovered by Crick and Koch in
the 1990s, but fell from favour when it was discovered that the
synchrony was with dendritic rather than axonal activity.
|
|